Recently, a former employee of a HEYTEA franchise store publicly shared on social media their experience of unfair employment treatment, quickly sparking heated discussion among netizens. The employee posted clock-in records and chat screenshots, pointing out that they had worked overtime for a long time without ever receiving overtime pay, but were instead deducted 700 yuan for being late, and the promised base salary did not match reality. More notably, the franchise store's autonomy in salary management made it difficult to protect employee rights, bringing the disparity in treatment between directly operated stores and franchise stores to the surface. This article summarizes the course of events and various viewpoints for reference by coffee industry practitioners. [more…]

Recently, coffee brand Seesaw was exposed for owing wages to about 75 employees in the Shanghai region, involving both store and back-office staff. Former employees reported that since late last year, wage payments have been irregular, and social security and housing fund contributions have also been suspended, while founder Wu Xiaomei has "read but not replied" to employees' demands. At the same time, Seesaw's nationwide store count has shrunk dramatically, with only 49 stores remaining, and some stores have closed due to material shortages and cut-off supplies of ingredients. This article reviews the course of the incident and the employees' experiences, and retains relevant recommendations from Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Seesaw, once hailed as one of the representative specialty coffee brands in China, has recently suffered a series of setbacks. Its last store in Chengdu was evicted after the shopping mall terminated the lease early; employees exposed illegal dismissals and successfully defended their rights through legal channels; and the founder was once again subject to high-consumption restrictions due to contract disputes, while the company's equity was frozen and debts were enforced through the courts. A stream of negative news has plunged this coffee brand, once favored by capital, into its darkest hour. This article will sort through the sequence of events and present the operational and legal difficulties Seesaw currently faces. [more…]

Recently, a Taiwanese netizen claiming to be a former Starbucks employee exposed on social media that a Starbucks power bank they received in 2023 suddenly overheated, emitted smoke, and exploded into flames during charging, nearly causing a larger accident. The product has a capacity of 10000mAh, supports 15W wireless charging, and is manufactured by Taiwan Life Factory International Co., Ltd. After the incident, the person contacted Starbucks customer service to report it, but received a negative response and was even fobbed off with the excuse that "after all, it has been used for two years," leaving them deeply disappointed. This incident has sparked discussions about corporate gift safety vetting and after-sales responsibility. As observers of coffee culture, Front Street Coffee also continuously monitors the quality of brand merchandise and consumer rights. [more…]

Manner Coffee has been thrust into the spotlight of public opinion due to three incidents of conflicts between staff and customers that occurred over two consecutive days. The brand issued an apology statement through its official Weibo in the evening, pledging to make improvements, but netizens did not accept the content of the statement, especially expressing dissatisfaction over the lack of a clear response to the incident in which "a customer broke into the bar area and assaulted a staff member." At the same time, the content of Manner's two official Douyin accounts has been completely cleared, sparking further speculation. Behind the incidents, media investigations and revelations from former employees have exposed that under Manner's rapid expansion, frontline baristas face high-intensity work, heavy psychological pressure, and an unreasonable compensation system. As one of the few brands in the industry with a thousand stores that still insists on using semi-automatic espresso machines, how Manner can strike a balance between efficiency, quality, and employee rights has become an urgent issue to be resolved. [more…]

Recently, a leak about Manner Coffee's discounted wages during the pandemic sparked heated discussion on social media. The leak claimed that Manner required employees to choose between two compensation options: hourly basic pay, or 80% of Shanghai's minimum wage of 2,072 yuan. The incident quickly trended on Weibo, and Manner subsequently issued a statement identifying two former employees as having made false claims, and said it had reported the matter to police to pursue criminal and civil liability. The statement also detailed wage payment standards during the pandemic, saying its treatment was far above Shanghai's minimum wage, and implicitly suggested that employees of competitor Mstand Coffee were involved. This article reviews the course of the incident, both sides' accounts, and lawyers' views, and explores the legality of barista pay during the pandemic and the state of the industry. [more…]

It is normally a heartwarming thing for a chain brand to show its employees' daily lives through its official WeChat account, but Chayan Yuese recently found itself caught up in a public opinion storm because of it. A post introducing the work and life of its store employees drew scrutiny for mentioning that staff were busy late into the night and did not finish until 3 a.m. Several netizens claiming to be former employees and part-timers came forward to confirm that working overtime until the early hours after closing was already the norm; regular customers, meanwhile, had plenty of complaints about the nonstop recorded spiel played in stores. When workers' helpless daily overtime is used as promotional material, has the warmth the brand wants to convey lost its flavor? This article walks you through the ins and outs of this controversy. [more…]

Recently, a Tims location in Toronto made headlines on social media after a soaked cockroach was found in an iced latte. The customer and a friend both fell ill after drinking it. Although they received a refund, they felt the brand did not take due responsibility. Even more shocking was the staff's unusually calm response, saying that cockroaches sometimes get mixed into iced coffee packaging and that the store could not completely prevent it. After the incident came to light, many netizens posted photos and videos of cockroaches crawling inside Tims stores, and exposed practices such as employees picking up dropped paper cups and continuing to use them, and grabbing Timbits with bare hands. Some former employees even posted photos of filthy back kitchens, saying they quit the same day they started work. Tims, once hailed as Canada's national pride, is now deterring both new and old customers due to frequent hygiene problems. This article summarizes the course of the incident and reactions from all sides, and includes Front Street brand recommendations and product information of interest to coffee lovers. [more…]

Seesaw, once hailed as one of the representatives of specialty coffee, is now mired in operational difficulties due to unpaid wages. Although employees at its Shanghai IFC store report to work on time, the company's wage arrears and cut-off of supplies have made it impossible to prepare drinks, forcing them to post a notice in Chinese, English, Korean, and Japanese to politely decline customer orders. From unpaid supplier payments to labor arbitration by former employees, from the founder being repeatedly subject to consumption restrictions to more than sixty economic disputes, this former coffee star brand is experiencing an unprecedented crisis. Many loyal customers have expressed regret and lament, while others have called on the brand to handle employee rights and interests with dignity. [more…]

Recently, a post on social media about Seesaw employees being owed wages and social security contributions has sparked widespread discussion. Chat records show that management admitted to operating difficulties and promised to pay salaries in installments, while key figures such as founder Wu Xiaomei and director Zhang Sai were also drawn into the discussion. In fact, Seesaw was already reported last year for issues such as delayed wages and suspended social security payments, and now it faces 19 judicial cases, with its last store in Chongqing also having closed. Although a new store in Changsha is still operating, this series of upheavals has led many coffee enthusiasts to lament: has the one-time benchmark of specialty coffee truly fallen into trouble? [more…]

Recently on social media, complaints from Manner baristas have been steadily rising. Many current or former employees have posted that even during promotional rushes, stores are only staffed by one person, making it difficult for baristas to even eat or use the restroom, and some ultimately choose to leave. What is striking is that multiple baristas say the concern from regular customers feels warmer than the company’s rules. At the same time, consumers also frequently encounter the awkward situation of arriving at a store with no staff present and being unable to refund or modify orders. From high-value specialty coffee to rapid, capital-driven expansion, Manner’s staffing gap is gradually coming to the surface. This article compiles complaints from multiple sources to present the dual perspectives of baristas and customers. [more…]

Recently, a news story about a milk tea shop employee who replaced the store's payment collection channel with a personal payment QR code and pocketed the revenue has attracted widespread attention. The shop owner exposed in-store surveillance footage on social media, showing the employee presenting a personal payment code to customers while working alone and inducing consumers to scan it by claiming the "payment device was malfunctioning." The owner said the account discrepancies had persisted for a long time, but the employee did not stop. The store has now collected all surveillance evidence and is preparing to call the police. This incident not only exposed loopholes in the store's daily management but also once again sparked discussions in the food and beverage industry about payment security and employee integrity. [more…]

In the coffee industry, it is not uncommon for employees to leave and later return to their original company. However, a former Luckin Coffee employee who tried to return to the bar in a part-time capacity after a two-year absence ran into repeated rejections. The recruiter explicitly stated that "those who have previously worked at Luckin cannot be rehired," a rule that has sparked confusion and discussion among many former employees. Compared with Starbucks' open attitude toward rehiring former employees, why is Luckin's recruitment policy so strict? Is it out of consideration for stability, or is there another reason? This article will walk you through the various perspectives behind this phenomenon. [more…]

Starbucks interim CEO Howard Schultz recently addressed employees via video, stating bluntly that many short-term decisions made by the previous management brought far-reaching negative impacts to the company and that promises to employees were not fulfilled. He revealed that feedback gathered in recent meetings mainly focused on issues such as insufficient training, unreasonable shift scheduling, and compensation and benefits that urgently need adjustment. At the same time, many stores also face difficulties such as a shortage of repair funds or delayed service after key equipment including ice machines and espresso machines broke down. Schultz promised to prioritize three core issues: personnel training, pay and benefits, and internal management, and assured that future commitments to employees will definitely be fulfilled. Since his return, Starbucks has suspended stock buybacks and fired its former chief legal counsel, but investors worry that profits will be squeezed, and the stock price continues to come under pressure. [more…]

Recently, the Wahaha Group has become a focal point of public opinion due to a collective lawsuit filed by several former employees. According to reports, since August, some employees have been required to terminate their contracts with the Wahaha Group and instead sign with Hongsheng Beverage Group, which is controlled by Zong Fuli, resulting in the cancellation of their original bonus dividend benefits. At the same time, the equity of Hangzhou Xiaoshan Shunfa Food Packaging Co., Ltd. was transferred to Zong Fuli's personal name for zero yuan, raising concerns among employees about investment returns. In response, Wahaha recently issued a statement claiming that some media reports are severely inaccurate, that the union has not received litigation information from the so-called rights protection committee, and that the equity repurchase and transfer are legal and valid. However, the statement did not mention key details such as the re-signing of contracts and the zero-yuan transfer, and many questions remain about the incident. [more…]

Recently, a rap lyric written by a Manner employee has sparked widespread discussion on social media. With candid words, the lyrics depict the real daily lives of baristas—catching early buses, strict attendance checks, pay disparities, and single-handedly coping with the intense pressure of sudden order surges—resonating strongly with many current and former employees, while also drawing outside skepticism over whether the post exaggerates the situation. This article examines the workplace details behind the lyrics, reconstructs the work pace and emotional challenges faced by Manner's workers, and explores the common circumstances of frontline staff at chain coffee brands. [more…]

Recently, news about a former employee of Chagee whose ID number was publicly displayed by a store quickly went viral online, sparking widespread attention. According to multiple netizens, a woman in Zhoukou, Henan, discovered after leaving the brand that her name and ID number had been posted on an in-store notice, along with a statement about dismissal and blacklisting. The store first claimed the notice was only to deal with a supervisory inspection, then changed its statement and said the identity information was forged. At present, the store manager involved has been suspended, and the brand has intervened in the investigation. The incident has also triggered public discussion about the legal boundaries of how companies handle employees' personal information. Does publicly displaying an ID number constitute infringement? This article will sort out the sequence of events. [more…]

Seesaw, once a thriving specialty coffee chain brand, now frequently makes the news due to legal issues. From being sued by former landlords, to multiple disputes with suppliers and former employees, to mass store closures in first-tier cities and a move to lower-tier markets with lackluster reviews, Seesaw's situation has drawn the attention and concern of many coffee enthusiasts. This article will review the recent turmoil surrounding Seesaw, analyze the operational difficulties behind it, and retain relevant recommendations from Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Recently, a video of a Cotti Coffee employee destroying a standee of former spokesperson Wang Yibo sparked a huge uproar on social media. In the video, the store clerk deliberately cut up the standee's face and posted it with a caption, provoking widespread discontent and a boycott among fans. As the incident continued to escalate, Cotti issued a public statement of apology on February 28, announcing the termination of cooperation with the store involved and its closure, while promising to strengthen training and oversight of the material recycling process. This controversy has brought the issue of material handling standards after the termination of brand endorsement contracts to the forefront, and has once again drawn industry attention to the protection of artists' portrait rights. [more…]

On his first day back as Starbucks CEO, Howard Schultz announced a pause on the stock buyback program, redirecting funds toward employee benefits and store operations. Behind this decision is a wave of unionization among U.S. Starbucks partners, driven by intense workloads and stagnant benefits. So far, 10 stores have voted to form unions, and more than 170 stores have applied to join. Schultz admitted that the company had let employees down in addressing store operations issues, and plans to invest $1 billion in wages, training, and benefits. This article examines the context of this transformation initiative and its impact on Starbucks' future operations. [more…]